Skip to main content

What managers can do to turn an online consumer review into a "helpful" one?

There is plenty of empirical evidence to support the positive relationship between online review ratings and a business's bottom line. Not all online reviews carry the same effect, however. Those reviews that are exposed to more internet users will have a bigger impact on a business than the ones that are barely read by others. 

Generally speaking, all of those websites allow consumers to vote on the helpfulness of an online review and tend to feature the reviews with more helpfulness votes on the front page. The reviews listed on the first page will have a better chance of being "discovered" and read by others. Meanwhile, managers are usually allowed to reply to an online review with one manager response.
I recently conducted an empirical analysis with another key investigator, Karen Xie at University of Denver. In this study, we drew our conclusions based on a linear regression model with 56,284 consumer reviewers and 10,797 manager responses from 1,405 hotels on TripAdvisor.com.
While the detailed report can be found in International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, with a blog discussion on MultiBriefs.com I am going to highlight the study's important findings and business implications as the following:

Factors contributing to the helpfulness of online reviews

We identified the following as the key influential factors that contribute to the helpfulness of online reviews:

  • Reviews with lower ratings
  • Reviews with fewer sentences
  • Reviews written by male reviewers
  • Reviews written by reviewers with higher status
  • Reviews written by reviewers with longer membership
  • Reviews written by those who visited more cities in the past
  • Reviews with a manager response

Implications for hotels and possibly other service businesses

  • Manager response is critical in general. It moderates the relationship between reviewer experience and the helpfulness of reviews in terms of reviewer status and length of membership.
  • Managers may respond to selective positive reviews to reinforce the positive reputation for the business.
  • Managers may respond to selective negative reviews with details of how they addressed the service failure issues, allowing potential consumers to form realistic expectations of the business.
  • Because "who" writes a review matters, managers may need to pay special attention to those reviews with fewer sentences, written by male reviewers or those reviewers with higher status and/or longer membership.
  • Because reviews with fewer sentences tend to be voted more helpful, managers should write a concise response just to get the key points across.

Implications for the webmasters on online review or retail websites

Webmasters may refer to our regression model and further test their existing algorithms. Then, we hope our model can help them do a better job in "predicting" those reviews with high potential of becoming "helpful" ones as soon as a product/service receives a consumer review.
If they have the power to predict the helpful reviews, webmasters can inform the business owners/managers with an auto-reminder so those reviews with a high potential of being voted helpful will be seen by the business owners/managers.
Then, the business owners/managers may decide how they want to deal with those helpful reviews. That way, the website will be able to provide more valuable service to their business partners as well as the consumers who are seeking "useful" reviews online.
Both Karen and I are hoping you will find our results and conclusions meaningful. In the end, we would like to encourage you to leave us some feedback and suggestions. Or let us know about any research or practical questions in your mind. If applicable, we would be glad to use the research questions you ask here in our future studies.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Is today's market too tough for upscale restaurants?

Operating a restaurant is never easy, but is it particularly challenging for upscale restaurants?

Restaurants Unlimited Inc., for instance, which operates 35 fine-dining and “polished casual” eateries, filed for bankruptcy in Delaware last week. Earlier in June, the Four Seasons Restaurant, an iconic spot for power lunch in Manhattan also closed for business after its reopening within less a year.

Are these two examples an isolated case or the tip of the iceberg? Then, if upscale restaurants are struggling to survive in today’s market, what challenges are they facing?

The rising labor cost

According to the Bloomberg report, Restaurant Unlimited Inc. hires 50 salaried employees at the chain’s headquarter in Seattle, plus another 168 full-time and 1,885 part-time restaurant workers. The rising wages in Seattle, San Francisco, and Portland have resulted in a total of $10.6 million wage expenses in the fiscal year of 2019. Nevertheless, its revenue for the year ended in May dropped 1%, at $…

Suggestive Selling – All You Have to Do is Ask!! (By Nicole Lee)

A simple, relatively normal thing occurred while in the drive-through at Del Taco with my boyfriend the other day.After placing our semi-high maintenance food order, the person taking my order, in a forced monotone voice, unenthusiastically asks, “Would you like to add our new blah, blah, blah for dessert?”All my sweet-tooth-driven ears heard was “dessert” and I wanted something sugary to complete my four-course drive-through meal. My boyfriend asked if I wanted the donut thing they were trying to push, but I ended up going with a churro.As we received our food, my boyfriend told the server, “Good job on the upsell.”In which we received the same unenthusiastic “thank you” in reply. This all led to a discussion about suggestive selling, how easy it is, how to do it correctly, and how beneficial it is.Of course, this Del Taco drive-through upsell experience did not meet our standards of how to do it correctly, but it worked!

Easy-Peasy
Both my boyfriend and I have sales and hospitality ba…

Want a job at McDonald’s? Now, it is as easy as talking to Alexa

McDonald’s Corporation introduced the world’s first voice-initiated job application process called McDonald’s Apply Thru. Now, job seekers can initiate the job application process through McDonald’s Apply Thru by taking to either Alexa or Google Assistant.

How McDonald’s Apply Thru works
The job application process begins with the applicants saying:
Alexa, help me get a job at McDonald’s.” 
or
“Google, help me get a job at McDonald’s.”
Then, the job applicants will need to answer a few basic questions, including their name, job of interest, and the location where they want to work.
Afterward, the job applicants will receive a text message with a hyperlink that will take the applicants to continue the rest of the application process.  
Where McDonald’s Apply Thru serve
McDonald’s Apply Thru is now available in nine countries, including the U.S., U.K., Canada, Australia, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, and Spain. It will be made available to other countries in the coming months.
Why McDona…