Skip to main content

Does trust encourage or discourage employees to share their suggestions? Research suggests the answer depends on the “types” of trust being measured.

The positive effects of employees’ trust in their supervisors have been widely documented, such as job engagement, performance, and organizational citizenship behaviors. Given supervisors’ authority in the workplace, we suspect supervisors would bear a critical role in initiating trusting supervisor-employee relationships. As suggested in the social exchange theory, employees may perceive supervisor trust in them as a kind act by the supervisor and feel obligated to return such a kind act with their trust in supervisor. 


The Research 


To examine the relationships among (supervisor) trust in employee, (employee) felt trust, and (employee) trust in supervisor with empirical data, I worked with Drs. Yung-Kuei Huang at National Ilan University in Taiwan and Ning-Kuang Chuang at Kent State University on a project. Our purpose is two-fold.  


1.    To examine the mediating relationships among trust in employee, felt trust, and trust in supervisor with two-dimensional measures:

  1. Reliance-based trust intentions --- trustors’ willingness to rely on trustees’ knowledge, skills, and abilities;
  2. Disclosure-based trust intentions --- trustors’ disclosure of sensitive or personal information to trustees. 


2.    To investigate the direct and indirect effects of the above trust-related variables on customer-focused voice and silence. 

  1. Customer-focused voice --- employees’ efforts to provide constructive suggestions to management with the intent to address customer needs and improve service quality and procedures;
  2. Customer-focused silence --- employees intentionally withhold information, ideas, and concerns that may be potentially important for the improvement or medication of customer services.  


We employed structured equation modeling with 307 valid paired supervisor-employee questionnaires from 32 hotels in Taiwan to test the hypotheses. We then published the results in the International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management.


The Key Findings


Besides the reciprocity of trust between supervisor trust in employee and employee trust in supervisor, we also discovered some key interesting findings about employees’ customer-focused voice and silence behaviors:  


  1. (Supervisor) reliance-based trust in employee has a significantly positive effect on voice but not silence. 
  2. (Employee) felt reliance positively affects voice but negatively affects silence.
  3. (Employee) felt disclosure has no impact on voice but positively affects silence.
  4. (Employee) reliance-based trust in supervisor negatively affects voice. 
  5. (Employee) disclosure-based trust in supervisor positively affects voice and negatively affects silence. 


Is relying on employees better than disclosing sensitive information to employees? 


It appears that supervisor reliance-based trust in employee can trigger employees’ feeling of being trusted by their supervisor. Then, when employees feel their supervisors rely on them, they would trust their supervisors in return. Furthermore, when supervisors rely more on employees at work, employees become more likely to provide constructive feedback and suggestions for service improvement. 


It is noteworthy to mention that when employees feel their supervisors disclose more sensitive and personal information, they become more likely to withhold their suggestions (i.e., to remain silent). It makes sense that employees might feel reluctant to provide suggestions or inputs when they see their supervisors often share personal and sensitive information with others. 


Our results indicate that employees will trust their supervisors more when their supervisors delegate more important tasks to them but not as much when their supervisors disclose too much personal or sensitive information to them. Accordingly, we present the following:  


Recommendations for Managers and Supervisors


  • Assign employees important tasks and give them decision latitude and autonomy to convey a stronger message of their trust in employees. 
  • At the same time, avoid overly delegating the number of important tasks.  
  • Establish a boundary with their subordinate, allowing them to better manage the amount and content of the personal/sensitive information shared with the employees. 
  • Actively welcome suggestions and inputs from frontline employees to minimize the negative effect of overly delegating important tasks on employee voice. 
  • Clearly and openly express their confidence and positive expectations about employees because employees also need to “feel” the trust before returning supervisors’ trust in them with their trust in supervisors. 


The Conclusion


No study is perfect or free from potential bias. While there are limitations, our work suggests that we must treat reliance-based trust differently from disclosure-based trust in future studies and practices about “trust” at work. Different trust-related variables can trigger psychological responses unique to customer-focused silence and voice. 


In what way do you see the differences between reliance- and disclosure-based trust? What best practices do you see in promoting employee trust in supervisor? How about best practices in helping employees feel or acknowledge their supervisor trust in them?  

Note: The picture was downloaded from


Popular posts from this blog

Luxury vs. Millennials and Their Technology: The Ritz-Carlton (By Julia Shorr)

Embodying the finest luxury experience, The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company, LLC has been established since 1983. In 1998, Marriott International purchased the brand offering it more opportunity for growth while being independently owned and operated. They are known for their enhanced service level as the motto states, “Ladies and Gentlemen serving Ladies and Gentlemen”. The luxury brand now carries 97 hotels and resorts internationally and is attempting to keep the aspects of luxury while keeping up with the trends of the technologically improving generations. The Varying Demographics of the Target Market The Ritz-Carlton’s typical target market includes: business executives, corporate, leisure travelers, typically middle-aged persons and elders, and families from the upper and upper-middle class section of society .   This infers a large range of types of travelers in which all are similar in that they are not opposed to spending extra for the luxurious ambiance. However, with

The challenges of SB 93 (California Senate Bill No. 93) will impose on the employers and their human resource management team (by Brittany Schaffer)

The COVID-19 pandemic started in early 2020, and it has caused massive changes within a short period of time. One of the most rememberable effects of the COVID-19 pandemic was that businesses had to come to a complete halt, forcing them to lay off employees. California's unemployment rates went up.  Now that the stay-at-home orders have lifted, people start to come out. Businesses are now reopening, looking to rehire their laid-off employees. Before the pandemic, employers had the option of recalling only a certain number of laid-off employees they would want to rehire based on employees' job performance. That option had been changed after Governor Gavin Newsome signed into law - Senate Bill 93, which went into effect on April 16th, 2021. The California Senate Bill No. 93 (SB 93) According to SB 93, companies in specific industries, mainly the hospitality industry, have the obligation to provide job opportunities in written form to qualified employees being laid off due to COVI

Want to win in future competitions? Invest in data-driven decisions now

Speaking of the permanent changes in the hospitality industry, many people will probably agree that demands for “bleisure”/“work-from-anywhere” travel and contactless self-service will continue to grow in the near future. Not everyone, however, realizes that data-driven decisions will become a key driver for growth in the industry, which has already affected how we do business now.   Automatic service enables businesses to capture more operational and consumer data for business decisions   One advantage of using automatic service comes from its ability to spontaneously capture and store real-time operational and consumer data for additional analysis. In the old-time when businesses still relied on workers to serve customers, operational data were collected usually through careful book-keeping, documentations, and observations; consumer data through market research were often limited to their perceptions, behavioral intentions, or past experience.     Now that automatic service is provi