Skip to main content

Human resource troubles in the workplace (by Robin Carapia)

 

One cannot operate a successful business without well-equipped human resource management. I work at a banquet hall in Claremont, California, and poor resource management was one of the top reasons why it was on the brink of going bankrupt before COVID-19 even hit!  
Not abiding by the law
At this establishment, hourly employees are required to take meal breaks in accordance with the number of hours worked, but they are never provided their ten-minute breaks. California law states that employers must permit uninterrupted breaks for nonexempt employees whose total work time per day is at least 3.5 hours. These are mandatory breaks that must be offered for 10 minutes for every four hours worked (CalChamber.com). Not authorizing breaks to employees that have worked four hours, is illegal and grounds for lawsuits. 
Not providing breaks to employees is unknowingly damaging employee morale, thus decreasing chances of motivation. According to one “motivational theory,” the Herzberg Theory, employees have two types of needs: hygiene factors and motivators. Employees expect hygiene factors to be present at the workplace, and if not, employees will likely feel dissatisfied. Rest breaks fall into this category, resulting in discontented employees who likely resent the workplace, do not feel respected for their work and thus not perform well. Guest service will likely suffer, leading to low rates of repeat customers, and decreases in profits. On the other hand, when hygiene factors are met, and motivators are fostered by management, they can make employees feel “satisfied” and thus motivated to perform well at work.
Employees who are not provided breaks, according to the External Equity Theory, will likely feel that they are treated unfairly in comparison to other employees in the same or similar position in other companies. These employees may likely work less hard and may convince others to work less hard in order to restore equity. They may develop a negative attitude toward the establishment and may not provide guests with quality service or may decide to work for another hospitality company instead.
Poor planning and recruiting
This establishment does not put a lot of energy and time into forecasting demand. Recruitment only takes place when someone quits, creating a rush to fill the vacancy. For this reason, they typically resort to hiring referrals. They are guilty of hiring “warm bodies” in order to fill a vacancy quickly. Because of this, an overwhelming majority of employees are affiliated with one another. Out of the twenty-four employees of this enterprise, eight of them are relatives from one family, three are relatives from another family, and 3 from another family. The dishwasher, chef, and cooks, and I are the only external hires, all other employees are friends of these families.  Hiring referrals simply because it’s the easiest, fastest, and most inexpensive way to fill a vacancy, could lead to hiring unqualified staff with low productivity, leading to lost profits. About sixty-five percent of the time, the selection process on its own will determine whether an operation ends up with a good performer or not. Managers should take anticipating demand more seriously and plan accordingly. They should develop a list of minimum qualifications that a candidate must possess to be considered for the position. Employers can also develop profiles of the characteristics that their successful employees hold, and actively search for candidates that have those characteristics, and not just settle on referrals.
The only qualification needed in order to get the job, after referral, is your availability to work weekends. No interviews are established, work experience is irrelevant, and they do not check references. Managers who fail to conduct thorough reference checks can leave an employer vulnerable to litigation for negligent hiring. Management must consistently and thoroughly perform reference and background checks, regardless of affiliation, to avoid potential lawsuits.  
Political overtones tend to rule the workplace when many employees are affiliated with one another. The number of hours scheduled, and promotions are highly attributable to relationships, instead of performance. Employees perceive such special treatment as internal inequities, which can lead to resentment toward the company and underperformance. Thus, an enterprise relying on referrals to meet its demand is highly undermining the importance of the recruiting process and how it can affect the business and overall profits. 
Management should take training seriously
On-the-Job training (OJT) is the only training provided for new employees at this establishment. This method can be effective, but it likely leads to trainees performing in the same manner as their trainer, which can be right or in many cases, wrong. I was trained on-the-job and one day I was yelled at by the owner of the banquet hall, she said I was cutting a wedding cake wrong. I was only doing what I had been taught. Supervisors or trained trainers should be involved in OJT in order for the training to be effective and teach the new employee the correct and expected ways to do their job, which can lead to a more productive staff, fewer mistakes, and ultimately more profits for the business.   
After taking this human resource class, are there things you would do differently if you oversaw the HR department at your job? What are some ways you can maintain a more productive team?  How would you utilize HR in order to increase profits?  

About the Author
Robin Carapia is presently a junior at Cal Poly Pomona. She is majoring in Hospitality Management with an emphasis in events. She began her education in hospitality at Chaffey College and later transferred to CPP. She works at an elementary school during the week and at the aforementioned banquet hall during the weekends. After receiving her bachelor’s degree from Cal Poly, she hopes to attain a management position at a convention center or at a hotel that features banquets. She aspires to open a restaurant or banquet hall of her own one day.

Works Cited
“California Meal Break & Rest Break Law (2019).” CalChamber. www.calchamber.com/california-labor-law/meal-and-rest-breaks. Accessed  4 November 2020

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The repositioning of Ten Ren’s Tea Time (by Eddie Long)

Ten Ren’s Tea was founded in 1953 and now operates one hundred retail stores globally, providing the finest teas to their loyal customers worldwide. Ten Ren’s combines modern technology and traditional methods when processing tea leaves to provide customers with the highest quality tea that aids in improving the quality of life and health for their customers. Ten Ren’s Tea Time, the restaurant, has a total of nine locations in the Southern California area. New Image: Ten Ren’s Tea Time recently changed its logo, as shown below. We can say that the marketing team wanted a change of the company’s logo to regain customer’s attention and regain their sales.  Just like they changed their logo, they also updated the website to fit the new theme. Their website appears more modernized than their previous design s, which can attract potential customers and returning customers. The company wanted to show its target market that they know what customers want and can accommodate any customer’s

Social media engagement is immune to COVID-19 (by Steven Valenzuela)

In the unparalleled world of COVID-19, individuals are flooded with choices: whether it be what to eat or what church service to watch. While there are marketing strategies to get consumers to purchase products to immediately increase sales, it may be a more beneficial to engage with low spending consumers in the short term, so that businesses can keep them for the long term.   Social media game strong   During this time, it is crucial to keep social media posts constant and consistently more than ever before. A recent podcast by eMarketer reports that social media outlets such as Facebook have seen a significant rise in usage. The reality is that individuals have more time on their hands, which is why it is important for businesses to utilize their free time to create content for their social media channels. In a recent interview with the hospitality net, Leland Pillsbury stated  “Customers are going to come back...And if you allow your competitors to reengage with the guests before

Do you know where your prospects hang out during the #DeleteFacebook movement?

Facebook used to the cool place where everybody hangs out. Not long ago, Facebook was ranked the most visited website in the world , and the website where Americans spent the most time. Facebook page then became the most popular social media platform for business-to-consumer communications among various types of organizations. In recent years, however, Facebook faced several backlashes toward the platform’s data privacy practices and its CEO. Facebook is experiencing some challenges of maintaining its popularity among internet users, some of whom even call for a #DeleteFacebook movement . I myself, also notice a shift in my teenaged students’ interest in Facebook, even before the #DeleteFacebook backlash. So, if Facebook is no longer the cool place where everybody hangs out, which social media platforms can we use to communicate with our prospective consumers? The most popular social media platforms among U.S. teens According to a 2018 Pew Research Center report