Skip to main content

What's Really Successful? External or Internal Recruitment and Hiring (by Hayley Arcaro)

Imagine working at a company for over three years but never getting moved up to a higher position. Imagine putting a substantial amount of your time into the company, being dedicated, working hard, and trying to be the best employee within the company, but without recognition. 

That must sound awful to current employees, especially when a company is trying to recruit top talents who want to grow with the company. Employers look for those quality employees and search for someone to represent their company in the best way possible. 

Restaurants strive to make their guests feel comfortable and to make sure they are having fun while at their establishment. They focus on “carefully choosing the people who take care of you.” Meaning, restaurants would carefully select and offer jobs to the most qualified applicants in the pool, who they believe can take care of every guest in the most respectful, reliable, and friendly manner, making sure the guests are having “a good time, every time”. Do restaurants focus on hiring and recruiting internally or externally? Based on my experience, after working in a front-of-the-house position at a well-known restaurant in San Dimas, I have seen a substantial amount of external hires rather than internal.

While external and internal hiring and recruitment can both have its benefits, focusing on external hiring can cause issues for a company, such as higher employee turnover, unreliable employees, unsuccessful employees, extensive training along with its cost, and moral problems with an internal staff (e.g., feeling unappreciated and undervalued). That was exactly what I have seen in the past three years.

When a dedicated, hard-working employee experiences a plethora of external hires,  the question arises: “Am I worthy of getting a promotion? Is my hard work valued?” I have asked myself the same question multiple times in my second year with the company. I started off at the bottom, just like any new hires with no restaurant experience. My first position was a hostess. From there, an outstanding host would be promoted to an expo, then later a server. Since many positions have been cut in the restaurant industry, including the expos and bussers, however, the only position that a host can move up to is a server. After I became a host for two years, however, I did whatever I could to show the management that I was worthy of a promotion. I learned "To-Go" and memorized the menu, and later became a lead To-Go hostess. Yet, I was only informed that I would be moved up “soon,” but since then, I had seen many new external hires to fill in the vacancies but not from within the company. I felt undervalued, and that this promotion would never happen. In the end, I requested to transfer back to the previous store where I began working with the restaurant chain and got trained to be a server there.

Later, I transferred back to the store in the San Dimas location, but I only witnessed even more external hires for host and server positions. Many hosts and hostesses who are waiting for a promotion became very upset. They stated they felt unappreciated and questioned why the management would not move them up within the company. Moreover, there were many problems with lots of the new external hires --- shortly after they hired, they quitted, were fired, had altercations with guests along with fellow employees, or would just stop showing up to their shifts. The employee turnover rate has become very high within the restaurant mainly due to the unreliable external hires. Wouldn’t it make more sense to move up trusted internal employees who have invested in the company, have shown their loyalty, and have been working hard?

Internal hires should have many advantages over external hires because they know the company, know the customers, and retain the knowledge taught in training while applying it to work, which would cost the company less in training. Accordingly, I recommend companies with high turnover rates first consider promoting internal employees that are trusted before hiring new external applicants. Yes, it is important to get “new blood" and gain new perspectives, but external hires might not be as valuable as some may think.

If you are a business owner, would you consider to hire an internal or an external candidate to fill in an important position? Would you spend money on training existing staff for his/her career development (for internal hires), or would you believe that an external hire was the way to go? How would you go about these decisions that will best suit your company?

About the Author 

Hayley Arcaro is the third year student at Cal Poly Pomona studying Hotel and Restaurant Management. She has three years of experience in the foodservice industry and just recently got hired at Kellogg West Conference and Events Center, located on the Cal Poly Pomona Campus, as a Front Desk Agent. During her spare time, she enjoys traveling to nearby cities, new tourist attractions, different states, and even different countries. She has traveled internationally to England, Scotland, France, Italy, and a few more locations in the Caribbean Islands.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Luxury vs. Millennials and Their Technology: The Ritz-Carlton (By Julia Shorr)

Embodying the finest luxury experience, The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company, LLC has been established since 1983. In 1998, Marriott International purchased the brand offering it more opportunity for growth while being independently owned and operated. They are known for their enhanced service level as the motto states, “Ladies and Gentlemen serving Ladies and Gentlemen”. The luxury brand now carries 97 hotels and resorts internationally and is attempting to keep the aspects of luxury while keeping up with the trends of the technologically improving generations. The Varying Demographics of the Target Market The Ritz-Carlton’s typical target market includes: business executives, corporate, leisure travelers, typically middle-aged persons and elders, and families from the upper and upper-middle class section of society .   This infers a large range of types of travelers in which all are similar in that they are not opposed to spending extra for the luxurious ambiance. However, with

The challenges of SB 93 (California Senate Bill No. 93) will impose on the employers and their human resource management team (by Brittany Schaffer)

The COVID-19 pandemic started in early 2020, and it has caused massive changes within a short period of time. One of the most rememberable effects of the COVID-19 pandemic was that businesses had to come to a complete halt, forcing them to lay off employees. California's unemployment rates went up.  Now that the stay-at-home orders have lifted, people start to come out. Businesses are now reopening, looking to rehire their laid-off employees. Before the pandemic, employers had the option of recalling only a certain number of laid-off employees they would want to rehire based on employees' job performance. That option had been changed after Governor Gavin Newsome signed into law - Senate Bill 93, which went into effect on April 16th, 2021. The California Senate Bill No. 93 (SB 93) According to SB 93, companies in specific industries, mainly the hospitality industry, have the obligation to provide job opportunities in written form to qualified employees being laid off due to COVI

Want to win in future competitions? Invest in data-driven decisions now

Speaking of the permanent changes in the hospitality industry, many people will probably agree that demands for “bleisure”/“work-from-anywhere” travel and contactless self-service will continue to grow in the near future. Not everyone, however, realizes that data-driven decisions will become a key driver for growth in the industry, which has already affected how we do business now.   Automatic service enables businesses to capture more operational and consumer data for business decisions   One advantage of using automatic service comes from its ability to spontaneously capture and store real-time operational and consumer data for additional analysis. In the old-time when businesses still relied on workers to serve customers, operational data were collected usually through careful book-keeping, documentations, and observations; consumer data through market research were often limited to their perceptions, behavioral intentions, or past experience.     Now that automatic service is provi